The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on November 18, 2026 that Maryland has the authority to enforce its sports wagering laws against prediction market platform Kalshi, deepening a growing legal war between states and the fast-expanding prediction markets industry. The ruling in Case No. 25-1892 is the third appellate loss for Kalshi in four tries, and it signals that the path to nationwide prediction market operations runs directly through a thicket of unresolved state gambling laws.
Fourth Circuit Upholds Maryland's Regulatory Authority Over Kalshi
The per curiam opinion found that the Commodity Exchange Act does not clearly preempt Maryland's gaming laws, even for event contracts traded on a CFTC-regulated designated contract market. That is the core argument Kalshi had been pressing: that federal oversight of its exchange should crowd out any state-level gambling enforcement. The Fourth Circuit rejected it. For related coverage, see How Crypto Influencers Are Navigating 2026 Disclosure Regulations.
The court also found no impossibility preemption and no obstacle to federal objectives, the two most common fallback arguments in federal preemption cases. Judge Roger Gregory, writing separately in concurrence, went further: he would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland's concurrent regulatory authority without a clear expression of that intent. Context on this theme: Binance $6.5B Freezing Order: Asia Session Roundup.
Maryland Attorney General Anthony G. Brown made the state's position plain after the ruling. "Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents," Brown stated, according to The Daily Hodl. More on this in Kraken Parent Payward to Acquire Tribe Capital.
The Fourth Circuit affirmed only the denial of a preliminary injunction. Maryland's underlying enforcement action against Kalshi is still pending before the district court, meaning this fight is far from over.
Why Maryland and Kalshi Clashed Over Prediction-Market Rules
Kalshi operates a CFTC-regulated exchange where users can bet on the outcome of real-world events, from election results to economic data releases to sports outcomes. The company has argued that its products are federally regulated financial instruments, specifically event contracts and swaps, not gambling products subject to state oversight.
Maryland disagreed and moved to enforce its sports wagering licensing laws against Kalshi's operations. That set up the central legal question: when a federally regulated exchange offers contracts tied to sporting events, can a state still apply its gambling rules?
What makes the Fourth Circuit decision particularly notable is the internal fracture among the three judges. Legal commentator Daniel Wallach broke down the split on X: Judge Gregory held the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt state gambling authority even if the contracts qualify as swaps. Judge Thacker, also in the majority, took a different route entirely, holding that sports event contracts are not swaps in the first place. Judge Benjamin dissented, arguing the contracts are swaps and federal law preempts state regulation.
Two judges, two separate reasons to rule against Kalshi. That kind of fractured majority is precisely the kind of legal muddle the Supreme Court eventually has to clean up.
Wallach, whose commentary on sports betting law is widely followed, put it bluntly: "Another win for the states. The Fourth Circuit's ruling against Kalshi makes it 3-1 for the states in federal appellate courts."
What the Decision Means for Kalshi and State Oversight
The appellate scoreboard now reads 3-1 in favor of state authority, per CoinDesk reporting. The Fourth Circuit joins the Sixth and Ninth Circuits in ruling that states can apply their gambling laws to Kalshi's event contracts. Only the Third Circuit, in a New Jersey case, has sided with Kalshi on federal preemption.
That circuit split is not an accident or a minor disagreement. It reflects a genuinely unresolved question about the scope of CFTC authority under the Commodity Exchange Act, one that lower courts cannot answer consistently and that only the Supreme Court can settle definitively.
Kalshi pushed back on the ruling's framing, calling it "a splintered decision, including three separate contradictory opinions," and arguing it "demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets," according to CoinDesk. That spin has some legal basis: a majority that cannot agree on the reason it ruled against you is a weaker precedent than a clean, unified opinion. It also feeds directly into a Supreme Court petition argument.
The regulatory backdrop is even more complicated. The CFTC, under Chair Mike Selig, has issued a 30-day directive ordering Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase, and other regulated exchanges to resume nationwide operations, creating a direct conflict with state court orders. Comply with the CFTC, and you risk violating a state injunction. Comply with the state order, and you risk defying your federal regulator. Senate Democrats, according to CoinDesk reporting, have called on the CFTC to withdraw its mandate, though that has not been independently confirmed from a primary Senate source.
The stakes extend well beyond Maryland. At least 16 other states have filed similar claims against prediction markets, according to Semafor. The Fourth Circuit ruling gives each of those states fresh ammunition and a circuit opinion they can cite in their own enforcement actions.
The scale of the industry under scrutiny is not trivial. Representative Ro Khanna noted that Kalshi users under 21 have already bet $3.9 billion on the platform, and described Kalshi as a $40 billion company. Those figures are driving political pressure for broader federal legislation that could restrict prediction markets regardless of how the preemption question resolves in court.
For Kalshi's Maryland-facing operations, the immediate effect is that the state's enforcement action moves forward at the district court level. No injunction protecting Kalshi's operations is in place. The company must either negotiate a path to compliance with Maryland's licensing requirements, as the AG has demanded, or continue litigating with the courts increasingly arrayed against it.
Crypto markets are already on edge. The Fear and Greed Index sat at 10, deep in extreme fear territory, as the ruling landed, though that reflects broad market conditions rather than the Kalshi decision specifically.
The industry's legal headwinds are building fast. With venture capital still flowing into prediction market platforms even as courts pile up against them, the question is whether a Supreme Court petition arrives before the litigation costs become existential, or whether one of those 16 state enforcement actions forces Kalshi's hand first. Either way, the prediction markets industry is running out of favorable appellate venues to find the answer it needs.
Editorial credits
Checked by TheCCPress QC Team before publishing on November 19, 2026 for counter-evidence, headline accuracy, metadata, commercial disclosure and authorship claims: our AI review system checks every article before it goes live, and our editor monitors it after publication. Report an error.
TheCCPress uses AI for research, drafting and review. Our editorial team is responsible for every article and corrects or withdraws articles when needed. How we review.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Cryptocurrency and digital asset markets carry significant risk. Always do your own research before making decisions.